Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by newsclues 11 days ago
Remember when America firebombed civilians during World War Two?
4 comments

That was, sadly, very much an "everybody does this" thing, from Guernica to Chongqing to Coventry.

But yes, there are two possible lessons from those horrors:

- never again must this happen to anyone: the construction of international peace frameworks, the ICC, and human rights law

- what is currently happening, which is very different

Wasn’t regret for and fear of the scale of that damage partly why we supported the Geneva Convention?
Ever heard about Laos?

"Between December of 1964 and March of 1973, the US launched more than 270 million cluster bombs on Laos during Operation Barrel Roll. This number is equivalent to dropping a full plane cargo load every 8 minutes, 24 hours a day, for 9 years. Laos is thus the most heavily bombed country in the world."

"The legacy of this once secret war continues today. More than 80,000,000 undetonated bombs are strewn across the country threatening the lives of its people."

https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/laos-the-most-heavily-bo...

"Since the end of the operation in 1973, over 20,000 people have died or been injured by these remaining bombs. At any moment, a farmer may strike one while plowing or a child may find one while playing. (...) Estimates suggest that as many as 100 civilians fall victim every year"

I’m not remotely claiming we didn’t do war crimes afterwards. Just that the firebombing, if I recall correctly, was explicitly cited as a reason why we needed rules going forward.
Unfortunately that knowledge seems to have been lost with the passage of time.
Quick question, who were the aggressors in that war? What had they done previously that might have warranted it?
The aggressors not being the targets of the firebombing is central to the concerns here. They weren't military targets (largely).
It was total war though, and they were the aggressors who had slaughtered millions of civilians previously. The Germans and Japanese got what they deserved.

Iran and their people are not the aggressors here. They do not deserve it.

My brother in Christ, why do you think the Geneva conventions were made!?