[tptacek]

If that's what this is, a bank-shot snarky criticism of the proposal, fair enough. I read it instead as a criticism of a stakeholder having the temerity to make a proposal in the first place. It's not their job to anticipate and capture all your objections. That's your job!

[pseudalopex]

Everyone holds a stake in this discussion. And intellectual honesty is everyone's obligation.

[tptacek]

Yes, that is a shorter way of saying what I just said.

[pseudalopex]

Amodei did not fail to anticipate and capture all objections. He dishonestly avoided well known objections. This was what you meant?

[tptacek]

No, it is not his job to state all the objections you might have to his proposal! That's your job.

[pseudalopex]

> all the objections you might have

My comment before corrected this straw man clearly.