Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by win311fwg 7 days ago
> why would you invest in a factory or a business?

Because you cannot afford to join the ranks of the investment class, so what else are you going to do with your time?

You are quite right that you are not going to build your business in London, though. You are going to take your business to places where starting a new business makes sense.

For the American audience, Detroit lived what you describe. What started as a vibrant manufacturing centre turned to property investment and soon it could no longer sustain itself. The people not benefiting from those investments there didn't throw in the towel, though. They packed their bags for what we now know as Silicon Valley and started new businesses developing the transistor. The economy wasn't killed, it moved.

> We should absolutely punish rampant speculation by heavily taxing land hoarding.

The law is to the will of the people, so this can happen on a whim, but you have to convince the people that piling everyone into a giant heap is desirable. Most people don't want to live in one giant heap. A Kowloon Walled City-esq world is a thing of nightmares for the population at large. Most people want people to move around, to make use of the entire world, not all settle in one place. These economic factors are the engine that pushes people to spread out.