Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by panick21_ 1 day ago
Monorails suck and are properity garabage. Is a recepy for bad transit at increase cost.
3 comments

This one seems to work... surprisingly well, considering how bonkers it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuppertal_Schwebebahn

I've always wondered why they've been so generally unsuccessful; conventional elevated rail works fairly well, and at least in theory they should be much cheaper and less obtrusive.

I didnt say they dont work. You just end up with highly costume properitery stuff.
Sure, but there's no reason that _has_ to be the case. Like, there've been attempts at standards; the volume is just never really there to make any of them _the_ standard.

Underground metro systems mostly started off as deeply weird and proprietary, as well (look at this one, weird gauge, tiny little trains, originally _cable_ operated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glasgow_Subway), but nowadays they're _fairly_ standard, say.

This. The general concept of "terrible public transport tech disguising as a good & novel idea" has a name: gadgetbahn.
Japan has plenty of monorails and they work great. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monorails_in_Japan
Yes they work but not better then normal trains and worse in some ways. Qnd in terms of sharing infrastructure maintaince, signaling and so on its worse.