Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ssl-3 1 day ago
> Because ai cannot do hardware

It can.

> it cannot solder wire

Plenty of placement and soldering machines exist that are far faster than humans. They just aren't yet integrated with the bot.

For the stuff that is unusual or particularly difficult, just add a human. Same as with code.

> it cannot replace red led with blue one and find current limiting resistor for optimal brightness

Sure it can. Just add a camera.

> It cannot see what part of enclosure needs to be cut.

Challenge accepted.

> It cannot see the startup transient on the ldo.

It can see that using the same tools we use to observe such things. https://github.com/aimoda/rigol-dho824-mcp

2 comments

And one needs to think from the outcome perspective too: maybe it is too hard to cut the part of the enclosure, but can it 3D print a new one hollowed out exactly where needed?
Or, I mean: This is a [hypothetical] human hackathon that is tainted by bots, not a bot hackathon that is devoid of humans [although I'm sure we'll have those some day as well].

Instructions that deliberately lack specificity, like "Drill a hole for the switch and then mount it" work fine in meatspace whether those instructions are issued by a bot or a human teammate.

Not at the entry price point of a hackathon, which is the point. Using AI in software hackathons are magnitudes cheaper than AI doing manual labor in hardware hackathons.