[Rohansi]

> This user might be okay with their data going to this other provider, but what about the people they’re messaging? I have a responsibility and a commitment to _all_ of my users to protect their data.

That's nice of you but your users are going to just copy-paste data to and from ChatGPT anyway.

[e28eta]

I think the difference is in the scale. I think Apple’s asking you to index / share all of the data from your app. Virtually no user is going to copy & paste every single message into ChatGPT.

And so I think there’s a meaningful difference between the app donating all the data automatically, vs making the data available to the user who is free to share what they want.