Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Smaug123 3 days ago
Does it have a terse syntax? I main F#, and when I have to work with Python I generally find myself complaining about how verbose it is. (Needing intermediate variables for what should have been a pipeline, the ceremony around parallelism, having to store constructor parameters as object fields, etc.)
1 comments

It sure does in comparison with most mainstream statically typed languages — if you feel that way about Python, I wonder what you say about Java, C++ or even Rust or Go?

Checking some examples at https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/fsharp/tour, I'd say it's quite similar in verbosity — eg. no need to declare a module in Python since the code already lives in a file that is the module (plus one less indentation level for module level functions); inline function declaration and calling is thereabouts with F# slightly more terse (let vs lambda + spaces vs parenthesis); if-then more verbose in F# (no then in Python, just "if x:"); F# does not seem to need "return"...

In many cases you can avoid intermediate varibles: inline ifs, list comprehensions, lambdas, etc... Constructor arguments are a good point, but this is mostly about idiomatic use instead of language itself: you can simply do

  def __init__(self, **kwargs):
      self.args = kwargs
I'll give you one on the ceremony around concurrency, though! I have different ideas of how it should have been done to shift the cost to the language runtime instead of the developer, but alas... :)