[mrandish]

> I'm interested in audio out because I dabble in musical instruments.

Sorry, I don't know. I'm just responding to echo and expand on another reply that Bluetooth for anything related to serious music, from audio playback to MIDI input is a dumpster fire on Windows.

Several years ago I tried to set up a high-end Windows laptop for hobby DAW composition on the go. The real-world BT audio latency just from laptop to headphones/earbuds was unworkable and, separately, the input latency from BT midi controllers was unworkable. Stacked together the total lag was laughable.

At the time, the issues were widely known and much lamented. Some tech blogs (including one at MSFT) indicated there were issues at every level of the stack (drivers, firmware, silicon) and work was proceeding to address the end to end shit show. The only workable Windows solutions referenced online involved using specific non-Bluetooth wireless devices. Needing to have a dedicated USB dongle hanging off the laptop combined with having a choice of either one specific device or a receiver dongle to support all devices, is less appealing than just having a wire.

Since then I've looked again every year or so but have seen no reports yet of meaningful progress and there's even less discussion of work in progress. Very disappointing. And the situation on the BT audio quality side doesn't seem much better. If you don't want degraded audio quality it's either choosing very specific devices which support a proprietary BT codec or switching to non-BT wireless dongle hardware. At least there is talk of improvement on audio quality but no clear indication better baseline minimum audio quality will ever be mandated in the BT audio standard.

If anyone has info the baseline latency or quality (input or output) of standard BT devices in Windows configs will improve, I'd be delighted to hear it.

[bobmcnamara]

I'll mention that you usually need to put the BT connection in a low latency audio profile or else you're likely to get something more suitable for mp3-style high buffer playback.

[mrandish]

Thanks for the tip. I'm about to revisit this again soon (new laptop + some free time for fun). Have you been able to get BT latency low enough on Windows to hit a MIDI key and hear the note without noticeable lag?

It's been a few years since the last time I actually tried it myself, instead of just checking user reports. I do remember I followed the DAW company's FAQ, set a mode in the DAW, and switched something in Windows settings related to BT. The wired latency (MIDI in and audio out) was excellent but switching either to BT tanked it.

It's frustrating that it appears to not have improved at all in a decade. I get the whole "good, fast, cheap" triangle and that most of the BT ecosystem only cares about "cheap" while being just good enough 128Kbps MP3s don't sound too much worse on $50 cuff link-sized earbuds. But I can't help naively thinking that on decadal timescales, the rising tide should lift even the "cheapest" corner of the triangle enough to yield slightly better minimum baseline quality - especially when it's been stuck forever at barely usable. Even more surprising is that BT gaming controllers still have such high latency, most BT controllers also come with a proprietary wireless dongle. Talk about pointless COGS and landfill.

I guess maybe the reason is those who really care can go wired, use non-BT wireless dongles or lock themselves to a proprietary vendor who controls both ends of the stack. But it kind of nerfs the point of having a short range wireless "standard" if doesn't cut COGS, landfill waste and never improves more 'serious' use cases even a little.

[bobmcnamara]

Try connecting in BT HFP mode. It will limit the audio bandwidth but gives fixed, tight latency on BT2+