[goodmythical]

People always look at me weird when I confidently answer "maybe" to real world instances of this kind of scenario.

It's always the same "if this is true, then that, so because this is true, then that must be true." and I say "maybe" and defend with "Your premise might be situationally correct, but we've no way of knowing whether it's True." followed by some such Bulls, though I usually use "what if they got hit by a car".