Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by steve1977 17 days ago
That's not what I said though. I just said you're giving away liberties.

For example, at home, I'm free to walk around nude and scream.

On a plane, I'm not.

2 comments

On a commercial passenger plane it's frowned upon.

On planes in general, many people jump nude for their 100th skydive - the original and best video of this has been scrubbed from youtube, but a quick search shows others.

Often screaming is included.

> the original and best video of this has been scrubbed from youtube

More US censorship. Nude skydiving, terrible. Indepth reviews of how to kill things with insane levels of weaponry? Featured video time.

To be fair, the weaponry is far less floppy.
On most commercial flights, it's not only frowned upon.

But if you want to f$ck around and find out, I'm sure it will make for a fun "How I Ended Up On the No Fly List" story.

> But if you want to f$ck around and find out

It's a tale as old as the USA

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mile_high_club

Usually the mile high club doesn't involve walking around in the nude though?
The last time I walked about nude in the main body of a commercial passenger aircraft (nominally a 30-40 seater) it was returning to Singapore from Vũng Tàu with only four people aboard, pilot and co pilot, myself and another surveyor.

Long story, short version - it doesn't always involve sex and isn't always restricted to toilets.

Been there, done that, still allowed to fly. Go figure.
> I just said you're giving away liberties.

>>this is even written somewhere in the contract between you and the airline that you agreed on

What I wanted to say is that you'll never give up any civil liberties because of a contract alone. If the contract can take those away it's because a law never gave them to you in those circumstances in the first place, so you never had them to begin with.

I just wanted to make it clear that you cannot agree to give up something that the law gives you. If the law doesn't give you something, you have nothing to give up.

The law gives very few liberties. And the places where people think it give liberties, it is actually just banning laws from being made around liberties.

Freedom of speech is the peak of this. People think it means "I can say whatever I like wherever I like". But that's not what it is. The government cannot make laws curtailing speech (though, it does... enforcement and interpretation don't line up with the original intent). You can, however, sign an NDA which curtails your speech. A business can kick you out for saying something they don't like. An employer can fire you for saying "poodle" one too many times.

And that's what we are dealing with around airlines. They absolutely can kick you off the plane and ban you for almost any reason. For what you say, wear, or because they don't like how tall or short you are.

The law really only protects a few things. Your race, your gender, your religion. Everything else is fair game for a private institution to discriminate against. They can kick you off a plane because you are a journalist. They can kick you off because you won't quarter soldiers. They can kick you off because you don't submit to a search of all your property.

  > The law gives very few liberties.
  > Freedom of speech is the peak of this. 
Freedom of speech isn't something the law gives you. It is something you innately have.

Don't confuse positive and negative rights[0]. Freedom of speech is something that can only be taken away. It is never something that can be given to you.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights

> It is something you innately have.

That is nonsense. "Freedoms" and "rights" are inherently social constructs. What does it even mean to say you "innately have" freedom of speech? That is a borderline religious claim, like saying you innately have a soul.