Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Bender 22 days ago
TLD servers are just another level of root servers. Each TLD does have a primary registrar that manages them however they provide access to thousands of registrars to manage the glue records at that layer. They are still collectively part of the root servers even if they are not under the domain root-servers.net. My registrar does not manage them. Nobody here is on a regisrar that manages the TLD root servers. The only permission my registrar and most registrars have is to update glue records for the domains their domain clients own and to add their domains. I and every DNS admin I've ever know collectively refers to all levels of the root and TLD servers as root servers. Even if that is technically incorrect that is how we have always referred to them. I think that distinction would primarily mater for people that worked at one of the high level registrars that manages the anycast clusters of tld root servers. At least I think that is where the confusion started. This was fun we should do this again. I updated the blawg to add (TLD) in reference to root servers.
1 comments
toast0 22 days ago
If every level is a root, then the word root means nothing. I guess you could say that the root servers point to the tld root servers that point to your domain's root servers. But then root server just means dns server.

I never mentioned registrars, only registries.

> Nobody here is on a regisrar that manages the TLD root servers.

I have a .is domain. For .is and some of the other country code tlds, you contract directly with the entity managing the TLD and its servers.

link
Bender 22 days ago
Are you secretly the admin of archive.is? He's made accounts on here before but they were all temporary. I want to believe he has an account that has been here a long time.
link
toast0 22 days ago
No, I live on an island, and is is a usps acceptable abbreviation for island ... I was trying to convince my spouse to leave yahoo mail for mail hosted on one of our domains by getting a domain that's less out there than enslaves.us, so I have islandname.is (well not literally that).

Tldr, a cool domain name isn't enough to make a switch happen.

link