[Dylan16807]

Are there actual people suggesting this or did you combine multiple posts that were arguing different things?

[kylling]

The parent suggests MCP as a way to secure credentials and enforce guardrails, and sibling comments iterate on this. I might be reading a bit between the lines with my comment, but did not intend to derail the discussion.

[Dylan16807]

But the parent who suggested MCP for security didn't say anything about vibe coding it. The person who talked about vibe coding an MCP was the one saying MCP isn't very useful.

[estetlinus]

Who in their right mind writes an MCP server by hand? Of course you vibe code them.

[Dylan16807]

Those are not the only two options.

[kylling]

They describe how MCPs are used and implemented in practice.