Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ponector 18 days ago
Achievements of SpaceX are enormous. But is US actually far ahead? Both China and EU have pretty much the same capabilities for space exploration.
3 comments

This is incorrect. If you look at the total size of Space sector, US dominates. Total amount of launches and sats, the US dominates. Total size of spend on civilian research, NASA dominates. Total spent by DoD, US dominates.

Amount of starups and new company formation in space, US dominates.

SpaceX alone dominates so completely that almost everything else is noise. And if you remove SpaceX, the US still ahead in most categories.

> Both China and EU have pretty much the same capabilities for space exploration.

China maybe soon, but the EU is not close.

Ariane 6 is in no way comparable to either SLS or Starship or New Glenn. It does 10t to low-earth orbit, 4t to lunar-transfer orbit.

For comparison, the Saturn 5 was 140 tonnes to LEO and 43.5 tonnes to TLI.
China is behind and making progress, but still hasn’t hit key milestone the US hit decades ago. The EU isn’t even close.
You can say the same about US: still hasn't hit key milestone US hit decades ago.