Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by singingtoday 20 days ago
Something about this writing feels off, but for the life of me I can't say exactly what.
9 comments

It's the writing of someone who has been writing articles like this for decades now, instead of your average blogger or journalist. Just enjoy the difference.
Can confirm! I've been reading Rands for 20 years now
I love how he went back and updated some of his older but still relevant writings, like https://randsinrepose.com/archives/nadd/.
To me, as a non-native speaker it feels like a series of interruptions and focus changes with no natural flow. Hard to follow.
It's awfully literary. It reads like James Joyce attempting to convey advice about effective leadership for technical teams. In my opinion, it's an obnoxious, pretentious approach to writing about practical subjects, but I may be in the minority.
This is just how he writes. Busy-executive-bullet-point style. Its not AI.
I think it's just a characteristic voice. Just like you can tell Vonnegut, DFW, or Palahniuk from a couple paragraphs, Rands developed a pretty distinct sound.
It's that opening paragraph.

> Coffee in hand, I sit down in the Cave. Any Tuesday during the work week, a sip, and I parse the calendar.

How many Tuesdays are there in his work week?

3-5, usually. Tuesday is used as a placeholder for "generic day like any other". Monday & Friday might be special, or they might not. But Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday are generic & interchangeable: you're not catching up after a weekend, and there's a work day the next day so there will be time to catch issues. They're Tuesdays in spirit, if not in fact.
Interesting, I've never come across this usage but makes sense.
My work week consists of five Tuesdays. It's the seventh best day of the week.
Very. Short. Sentences. That’s AI
AI is trained on but more importantly prompted to write in that style. It's not just annoying⸻it's a choice.
Wrong. Look at the author's long history of posts.
its fucking rands. Jesus.
Terminal LinkedIn brain
Look up the organizational chart meme. Look at Amazon's chart. You'll know what's off.