Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gmd63 19 days ago
Most Americans didn't vote for Trump.
3 comments

And even fewer would vote for him today vs Nov 2024. He's at ~39% approval at this point. So, I disagree with the comment above which said that most americans voted for / support this.
This is true in the absolute, not just in this special case but in almost all national level elections of any democratic country. I am going out on a limb here, but I think this is mostly true.

"Most Americans voted", really has now come to mean most of the voting citizens voted for him. Now I wonder if that qualified statement is true or not.

BTW I did not downvote.

As pointed out: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48304293

Less than half of the actual voted citizens voted for him (or, for those that prefer, almost half of the actually voted citizens voted for him)

Probably even less would have voted for him if there'd been an effective opposition you could vote for instead.
Noted.
> This is true in the absolute, not just in this special case but in almost all national level elections of any democratic country.

Australia would like to remind everyone we have compulsory voting.

Just out of curiosity: what happens to you if you don't vote? Can you get a medical excuse? What if you are traveling?l
Good excuses work. But they have to be good:

- "travelling": why didn't you postal vote?

- "medical": we allow pre-voting; was it planned?

Just paying the fine without arguing on time gets you a 50% discount in state voting. And it's a token fine - $20 or so from memory for federal ballots. Besides you don't have to vote. The requirement is you turn up, or give them a piece of paper if you post it. This is deemed so important when we designed our own voting machines (which were never deployed), they had an explicit "I decline to vote" option.

The paper can be blank, but people are often more imaginative. I can't find the reference to it now, but one paper had penises of different lengths drawn beside each option. The Australian Electoral Commission is required by law to "save" votes, which means that even if it wasn't marked strictly according to the rules if a reasonable person could infer the intention, it counted. This particular vote worked its way through the courts, where it was eventually struck down. Reason: it was impossible to know if a longer penis meant it was more or less favourable to the candidate.

About 8% of ballots can't be saved. Of those around about 2% are deliberately spoilt - the rest are mistakes. If Vanessa Teague's voting machines (with the decline button) had been deployed, the remaining 6% would have gone away.

Not sure why this is downvoted. Objectively true. Less than 50% of the popular vote, and that's just voting Americans.
Trump 2024 won the popular vote (surprisingly; I think that was the first time a Republican did that since the 1980s).
Trump 2024 won 49.8% of the vote versus Harris' 48.3%, out of the 65.3% of eligible voters who voted (about 154 million of 174 million people.)

Trump's exact vote tally was 77,284,118. That many people voted for him, versus 74,999,166 for Harris (with Trump's margin of victory being 2,284,952 votes.)

There are approximately 300 million Americans. So even though Trump "won the popular vote" it it still correct that most Americans didn't vote for Trump. Not even more than half of voters voted for Trump. Trump having "won the popular vote" does not in any way mean that a majority of Americans or even voters supported him, that just isn't the way the system works.