Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Fnoord 15 days ago
Going for a cup of coffee means physical walk. Detaching from focussed mode means your mind gets in diffused mode. This is where/when creativity ensues.

One thing to remember is 2.5 gbit/sec uplink is shared between all clients. So if one client is on 1 gbit, and one client could saturate their 1 gbit while switch and router can handle better. An advantage of that is QoS isn't needed to be applied manually.

So, for example, it maybe worth it to have higher than 1 gbit uplink on switch to router, and maybe a server to switch, but devices such as your TV or WLAN clients do not need such.

75 mbit up is pretty good compared to DSL (I bet it is cable), and yes 1 gbit up is nice for off-site backups. But the upsell of going above 1 gbit symmetric IMO isn't there.

Cable providers know this. Which is why they sit below 1 gbit symmetric, at a level average subscribers are comfortable with.

1 comments

> Going for a cup of coffee means physical walk. Detaching from focussed mode means your mind gets in diffused mode. This is where/when creativity ensues.

Sure, but I want to choose when I do it, not have it forced upon me.

> 75 mbit up is pretty good compared to DSL (I bet it is cable)

It is FTTP not DSL or cable. BT Fibre 500 in the UK. Almost all of the deals through the legacy/monopoly provider (BT/Openreach) are asymmetric like this.

The 2500/2500 at the new property is a different provider that has their own network and so isn't tied into reselling Openreach's GPON infra.

Asymmetric fiber, ridiculous. That changes everything TBH. I didn't expect that to exist in 2026.
https://communityfibre.co.uk/fibre-deals for reference

[EDIT] The asymmetric supplier is BT via Openreach. Google something like "BT Fibre 500".