Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by miltonlost 15 days ago
How is going back to a policy that used to work "vague and unactionable"? It literally had been actionable.
1 comments

It did not work though. Bell and Standard Oil are notable examples. What else?
> It did not work though. Bell and Standard Oil are notable examples. What else?

That's pretty unfair. IIRC, Standard Oil was on of the companies that was the impetus for antitrust law (and broken up by it), and AT&T was broken up (famously) in the 80s.

Basically, your "argument" is a troll or a deep and basic misunderstanding. Especially in the case of Standard Oil. You're basically saying the law doesn't work because it didn't work before it existed (Standard Oil became dominant in the 1870s or 1880s and the Sherman Antitrust act wasn't passed until 1890).