[wookietrader]

The breakthrough was the insight that while you cannot train a deep neural net at once with backprop, you can train one layer after the other greedily with an unsupervised objective and later fine tune it with standard backprop.

Years later, Swiss researchers (Dan Ciresan et al) found that you can train neural nets with backprop, but you need lots of training time and lots of data. You can only achieve this by making use GPUs, otherwise it would take months.

[iskander]

You can't train fully connected deep models with backprop, or at least not easily or well. An alternative solution to this problem is spatial weight pooling (Yann's convolutional networks) which play well with SGD.

[mark_l_watson]

That is correct. The problem is that the gradients get smaller and smaller as you back propagate back towards the input layer. So learning on the front part of the net is slow. Hinton has a lot of good material about htis in his Coursera lectures.

[wookietrader]

Yes you can.

Check out the publications by Ciresan on MNIST, have a look at Hinton's dropout paper or at the Kaggle competition that used deep nets. Or try it yourself and spend a descent amount of time on hyper parameter tuning. :)

[iskander]

Which of Ciresan's projects are you referring to? Everything I've seen by him uses convolutional layers of some sort.