Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by yogthos 29 days ago
unions work
1 comments

But who will protect the interests of capital??
But won't somebody think of the robber barons!
Capital, politicians, conservatives, libertarians,
We’ve gotta add American Liberals, majority of Democratic Party to the list. The Sanders faction is unfortunately not yet the prevailing force.
At the very top, yes and unfortunately many workers on both sides of the fence run interference/collaborate for those at the top it’s one of reasons the Molly Maguire‘s never win or rarely win for too long.
Around the world "liberal" is synonymous with "capitalist". US is pretty unique in that it considers liberalism a leftwing ideology
Left/Right alignment is relative, and the American political center is...where it is, and has been drifting rightward since Bill Clinton's "Third Way".
No longer true; the left wing in the U.S. started splitting from the liberals over a decade ago and that's more or less complete at this point.
Yeah for sure, speaking purely on the American common framing of big L Liberals as akin to social liberals rather than classical/economic liberals.
Don't forget liberals too!
I think you mean who will protect the interests of the consumer? That's ultimately who loses to unions. There's no direct ethical value in protecting businesses or their owners but workers and consumers include pretty much all humans and their interests are in tension with each other.
Consumers have a choice of not buying, so generally they do not lose to unions.
Not generally, no. Workers usually do have choice - they can work in a less desirable job, just as consumers can buy a less desirable product. At the extremes, both are serious - workers without income can starve and consumers for whom food is too expensive can starve.
mostly the government because the consumer has a lot of democratic power.

product regulations and antitrust as examples

I mean if that is your measure, then consumers lose more to capital than organized labor.