Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by giancarlostoro 24 days ago
Pretty sure any IDE worth anything that has JS support pulls NPM packages at some point to lint code, no? You're not giving me much to be outraged about without more information. Zed tries to set things up for you so you're not wasting hours trying to figure out how to set them up in a brand new editor.
2 comments

I do not use JS and certainly was not doing anything JS-related, and I do very much not expect my tooling to silently run code from insecure Internet sources on my machine. Which does not seem like an outlandish position to me? If you consider that acceptable, yourself -- fair enough, that's your call and it's your machine, but let's please not label that anything but grossly insecure?
No doubt an unpopular opinion, but if I install an app that is going to do things in the background, I'm going to hold that apps developers responsible for any breaches. If Zed needs javascript to do its job, it probably should be downloading it from their own servers, or even better, just ship the editor with all the code it needs to do its job.
Yes, please ship everything that's needed because otherwise when I run your app in an isolated network namespace it will break. This also applies to builds. If I can't build your project from a clean git repo without internet access you are doing something wrong. (Yes I am aware that I likely just accused the majority of software devs of being wrong. I don't care I'm yelling at clouds here.)