Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by telchior 30 days ago
I think you've misunderstood the idea. Tim Bray and the OP of this thread aren't afraid to visit the US; the key phrase used in the post is "as a matter of principle".
1 comments

>there’s a significant risk of an extremely negative outcome. I have a family to support and really can’t afford that risk.

I can understand the principles and the bit of Canadian pride, but ultimately it's rather hyperbolic. Even on principle, the fact is Canada and the US are strong and long lasting allies with a very obvious power imbalance, and this sort of pouting over commentary is more fitting to members of an elementary school kickball team than a professional organization on the cutting edge of technology.

> the fact is Canada and the US are strong and long lasting allies

As historical fact, yes; but this is degrading in real time. As a Canadian, I can’t name a single family member, friend, peer or acquaintance who regards the U.S. as an ally. And on an official level, our PM has given multiple speeches, at Davos and elsewhere outlining Canada’s new status with respect to the U.S. In that void, Carney is actively seeking new economic and defence partnerships with Europe and others to replace the relationship that Canada and the U.S. previously enjoyed.

When one powerful neighbouring country repeatedly threatens your sovereignty it does predictable things to the ability to call yourselves “allies.”

>As a Canadian, I can’t name a single family member, friend, peer or acquaintance who regards the U.S. as an ally.

Is being melodramatic the new alternative to the famous Canadian politeness?

How would US citizens feel about Mexico if it had 3 billion people, 20x the military size, a history of annexations, and a deranged president joking about annexing the US? Still funny?
This is a naive response to the concerns Tim has expressed, and displays a deep lack of critical thinking around how the decline of the US' status in the world is impacting it's role as the home of "cutting edge technology".
US and Canada are not strong allies anymore. They are former allies with ongoing hostility between them.

As an example, US walked away from joint defense board just few days ago.

Canadians on the internet point out that many American don't understand the severe damage Trump has done. Your post is a great example for this.
That's probably correct,because I really don't see it, it's not like Canada can just move to Europe or something. They don't really have much of an option and neither does Europe for that matter. Is Canada going to let China have a military base or some other drastic measure?
Did you miss the point above that?

> But there’s also the issue of entering the US; if I roll up at the border and am asked to disclose my social media output, there’s a significant risk of an extremely negative outcome.

Its no longer the question of supporting "terrorists", we have seen what people can critcizing Trump, the dear leader, might have to go through.

Trump is are destroying American credibility all over the world and its others who are being hyperbolic?

Your naivete is the reason America will decline. You guys, well-intentioned and optimistic as you all are, are the frogs in the boiling pot, unaware of how much America has declined in the global eye. Fun fact, America ranks below China and even Russia in the latest perception polls.

Without you guys taking action in your country, there is no hope for America.