[kxrm]

> Without google crawling your site, you don't get any new traffic. But with google crawling your site, you also might not get any traffic.

I may be strange and unusual, but I just have never cared about my Google ranking. I know this makes me out of the ordinary among site owners but I have been humming along fine.

This certainly will disrupt traffic but for some of my sites I honestly think this is a good thing. I want you to want to be there, not just stumble upon my site because you happen to hit the right search keyword. Plus if it gets bad, this does create a new opportunity for others with cross linking and search.

[prinny_]

Only issue is what happens when the company that owns the search and has a dominant share of the browser market flags your site with the good old "warning: potential risk ahead" when people try to reach it directly? And buries the "I know the risk let me through" deep in the browser settings. Advocate for different browsers? Google is pushing web attestation in one form or the other. I wish the future would look bleak, because right now it's looking blue, red, yellow and green and it's worse.

[kxrm]

> Only issue is what happens when the company that owns the search and has a dominant share of the browser market flags your site with the good old "warning: potential risk ahead" when people try to reach it directly?

My target market is more technical then that so likely, nothing would change for me. Again, I recognize the impact of Google's dominance for some, but if the "attestation" isn't helpful and only hinders using services that people have come to rely on, there will be push back.

I also have been advocating for years for everyone in my circle to avoid using Chrome. A homogenized browser market is a risk, and Chrome is the new IE. I hope you are also a part of the effort to advocate for browser diversity.

[tardedmeme]

You could lose your domain name: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47151233

[account42]

Don't forget that other browsers also just use googles web good boy list and if you report false positives point you towards google and cover their ears.

[1718627440]

> flags your site with the good old "warning: potential risk ahead"

They are already training people to click these away.

[carlosjobim]

> I have been humming along fine.

Do you depend on site visitors for making a living? That's what this is about.

[kxrm]

Yes! However most of my users were established through my network, not search.

I know that sites relying on ad income will and are being hurt tremendously by this effort on Google's part. However, if you are in the startup space and make money on services you offer, search should be one of several strategies you are deploying for user growth.

[vasco]

This is like saying people should just win the lottery or something. Your conditions are extremely niche

[chadgpt3]

> I may be strange and unusual, but I just have never cared about my Google ranking.

But that's why you're a nobody instead of a million dollar startup founder. You didn't play the game, so, you lost. I lost too.