Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by antonID 4950 days ago
I agree that the laws shouldn't be as crazy as they are now, but why make it harder to catch file-sharers? It's illegal to share stuff like this, and I don't see any justifiable reason why this shouldn't be illegal. However, it should be a small fine in my opinion, and it's a waste of time to break down the doors of these people downloading music unless they are making a ton of money by selling this pirated content.
1 comments

I don't see any justifiable reason why this shouldn't be illegal

Because sharing is good and it's not our problem if the currently dominant business model has troubles with it?

Even if you think that sharing music freely should not be allowed, the fact remains that we are dealing with an industry that refuses to adapt to new technologies and new customer expectations, and engages in despicable conduct to preserve their outdated business model, as this story illustrates. In this view, accelerating the change, or doom, of this industry is rendering a service to society. Letting them go after file sharers is simply helping them resist change, and only by fighting the symptoms (we're losing some sales) rather than the causesĀ (it's easier to "pirate" than to download legally, legal downloads are too expensive and impose unwanted restrictions).