[sneak]

Who is this for? Is this to promote AI to the general Catholic public, or is it some kind of cultural signal to potential conservative institutional customers that Anthropic isn’t just a stereotypical bunch of godless California hippies?

Normally when I see these sorts of things it’s obvious what it is for and why, but this one confuses me.

[kelseyfrog]

My guess is that it (re)affirms that LLMs don't have souls and only people do.

If you've read any Vatican publications, the theme is being the authority on the ontology of reality.

EDIT: A decree for bioethics https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/docu... I'd expect a similar deal for AI.

[abirch]

I have met many people who don't seem to have a soul.

[Terr_]

> Ankh-Morpork! Brawling city of a hundred thousand souls! And, as the Patrician privately observed, ten times that number of actual people.

-- Guards! Guards! by Terry Pratchett

[femiagbabiaka]

All of the people who I agree with are ensouled, all of them I disagree with are not.

[SV_BubbleTime]

It makes celebrating their murders and assassinations just like so much easier to cheer for!!

(Yeah, it’s a problem, but they can’t see it)

[lovich]

What is your opinion on this quote?

“Robert Mueller just died. Good, I’m glad he’s dead. He can no longer hurt innocent people!”

[kelseyfrog]

Heretic!

[sgc]

I hope you saw others' correction to the title here that indicate Olah is just a speaker at an event on the same day, not an author (although he almost certainly was consulted for his opinions while the Pope and his assistants were working on the Encyclical). So what matters here is what the Pope is trying to do, not Olah's intentions in his minor role.

The Pope has already spoken quite a bit about ai, and exhorted priests to keep ai out of their homilies, which should be a sacred fruit of prayer and study.

Just from what I have seen he said and my Catholic Theological background, I would say he will definitely be talking about at least a couple things: 1) the relationship between ai and our intellectual labor, and how to use it fruitfully to grow without losing ourselves in it (a very similar concern to many on hn as far as I understand); and more importantly for him and again for many 2) how to use ai in society in a way that everybody can enjoy the fruits of it, instead of just the elite few (similar to the priority of Rerum novarum). This Pope chose his name because of this theme, and has consistently demonstrated that social justice is amongst his highest priority concerns - to the point that he has asked the Church to stop focusing so heavily on sexual ethics because there are such weighty injustices in the world that require our focused effort and attention.

[pavon]

The encyclical is for the Pope to express the church's view on AI and its impact to society to other Catholics. My guess for why Christopher Olah is there is to signal that Anthropic is the ethical AI company.

[dyauspitr]

It’s for me. It’s strange so I’m probably going to watch it. It helps that I generally like the modern Catholic church’s direction on things (besides abortion but I’m willing to overlook that).

[mrandish]

> Who is this for?

For the shrinking Catholic church it's trying to regain relevance. For Anthropic it's PR.

[ImJamal]

The Catholic Church is growing not shrinking?

[discreteevent]

There was an article in the FT a while ago about how confused and frustrated Trump was about the strait of Hormuz. The conclusion was that not everyone has a price but that concept was outside of the scope of his narrow mind.

[bigyabai]

It's part of the gradual agenda to label AI the antichrist.