Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by anon291 30 days ago
No conscious person can know if another person is conscious. There is no 'sensation' of experiencing another conscious. Given how many people can and have been fooled by AI, this lack of ability to sense another consciousness is clear.
1 comments
selcuka 30 days ago
That's the basis of the p-zombies thought experiment discussed (and dismissed without any real arguments) in the article.
link
skirmish 30 days ago
P-zombies cannot be argued about, if you reject their existence your opponent will call you a p-zombie (happened to Dennett).
link
selcuka 29 days ago
It's a fair point, though. If one rejects a subjective experience without any doubt, the most plausible explanation is that they don't have that subjective experience.

If I tell you that I see numbers as colours, and you say "that's not possible", I would assume that you don't have synesthesia [1]. I wouldn't doubt the fact that I have it [2].

Similarly, if some people argue that consciousness is not something like I describe, I would naturally assume that they don't experience it the same way as I do.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synesthesia

[2] Someone I know has synesthesia. I don't have any way to confirm or deny that. All I can say is I don't have it.

link