Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nickbarone 4950 days ago
My question is what kind of contaminants (or none!) this process picks up - If you're getting your water from a polluted atmosphere (say, LA), what kind of pollutants end up in your water? Or does it produce "ultra-pure" water, leading to weird health risks like hyponatremia?
3 comments

You won't get hyponatremia from overly "pure" or distilled water. The amount is water is utterly dwarfed by the amount in food.

If there are pollutants in air they will be in the water, but it's not a actually a problem because, although they might be bad to breath, most air pollutants are harmless when eaten.

Carbon (soot), Ozone, NOs, sulfur dioxide (smog), etc are harmless to eat.

Interesting. Are there any that are the other way around - dangerous when eaten, but not when inhaled?

I'd imagine it'd have to do with the digestive ecosystem, if there were any that worked that way.

I don't know of any.

But if there were it would be something that requires acid or digestion to "activate". Or perhaps something that can't be absorbed without something the only exists in the gut.

Bacteria actually could do that. Inhaled they would rapidly die, but in the gut they could live (more food for them) and cause illness.

Also, the gut will absorb things faster than the lungs. So I could easily imagine a toxin that has little effect when inhaled (since it's absorbed too slow to cause damage) but causes trouble when eaten (everything is absorbed at once).

But I don't know of any specifically.

I was wondering this as well. Does it need a purification process?
Your lungs are probably at least as efficient at pulling those pollutants out of the air and sending them straight into your bloodstream.

Any air that distills out water that was worse to drink than what was available locally would probably kill you to breathe just as quickly.