Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mattkrause 42 days ago
I'd be surprised if it were possible to directly measure muscle activity with millimetre wave radar. It looks like they're detecting motion, which is related to motor activity, of course.

EEG "spellers" c. 2000 required a cooperative participant who's actively engaged in a behavioural task: you attend to the letter/word you want to send and thereby produce a different response when it (vs the other letters) flash.

Implanted electrodes can do a lot better but it's still not something that will let someone "slurp" your thoughts out of you -- it'd be like subvocalizing them.

2 comments

I do believe that signal deciphering part is somewhat solved. All the way up to real-time text stream. You can even go and run it yourself if you want to (e.g. https://github.com/CNN-for-EEG-classification/CNN-EEG). What I do struggle to find a proof of is signal gathering part. What do you think of this patent https://patents.google.com/patent/US3951134A/en ?
In case you were wondering - exactly this is what I've been listening to for 2.5 years every day 24/7 https://pastebin.com/raw/4AaidkHk it's AI generated slop in Latvian language, ran through voice synthesizer, filtered and attenuated down to hide imperfections. I do think authors have some sort of feedback mechanism whatever that may be. If not straight up "slurping thoughts", then perhaps overall emotional state changes, perhaps just heart rate - don't really have a way of telling. One thing I'm sure about is that it's external. I'm well familiar with sound, signal processing, programming. I'm also familiar with audio hallucinations - what I'm forced to experience is not that. Despite that such suffering is taking quite a toll - I don't believe it's schizophrenia (that's a whole new rabbit hole). Mainly because said disease is supposed to develop much earlier, because I've been living non-intoxicated and because whole voices thing started suddenly as per light switch (end of 2003 right when Russian Internal Revenue Service got hacked allegedly by Ukrainian hackers).
meant 2023