Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by caymanjim 38 days ago
You say that like there's a difference. You say that like the detail of data that Google Analytics farms is acceptable. You say that like what Google does with the data is acceptable. Just because companies want the data doesn't mean they deserve it.
2 comments
repelsteeltje 38 days ago
Totally agree that Google should not be on a service like this in any shape or form.

But "sharing data" does somewhat suggest they are sharing the payload, the actual conversations.

link
simonw 38 days ago
What does Google do with analytics data that's not acceptable to you?

https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/1011397 says "Regardless of your data sharing settings, your Analytics data may also be used only insofar as necessary to Maintain and protect the Analytics service."

link
philipwhiuk 38 days ago
> Maintain and protect the Analytics service

This is a pretty broad leash.

"To maintain the analytics service we need to make money"

link
simonw 38 days ago
What's the absolute worst thing Google could be doing with that analytics data?
link
caymanjim 37 days ago
Selling the fact that you visited a suicide prevention website to anyone who cares to buy it. Google analytics knows exactly who you are the second you access a site that uses Analytics.

You don't have to be logged in. You don't even have to be a Google customer. They have IP and browser fingerprinting to uniquely identify people through aggregation of all their sources.

link
simonw 37 days ago
OK, there is a feasible way this could happen. Google would need to be using IP address plus browser device fingerprinting to identify users who visit Google Analytics sites, and would then need to be packaging that data to sell to advertisers.

I don't believe they do this, partly because if they did it would be something they would want to actively promote as a product to advertisers. Why do the creepy thing if you can't talk about it to make more money?

But technically I do believe it is feasible.

link
fsflover 38 days ago
Sell it to insurance companies, employers? Use it to target ads of snake oil to vulnerable people?
link
simonw 37 days ago
Sell what to insurance companies?

All they have is that there was a hit from an IP at a specific date and time. Any cookies they set will let them tell that the same browser came back an hour later - but won't let them join traffic together across multiple sites.

link
fsflover 37 days ago
IP can be correlated with other data to infer the identity. Google ads are everywhere, so Google probably knows, who you are and your IP.
link