Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by deng 34 days ago
So telling someone to make a table for you is more human than making it yourself, because you're using natural language instead of saws and hand planes?
4 comments

I would say yes, conversing between two humans, maybe even collaborating, is more human than a solitary human using inanimate objects.
Basket weaving is more human than conversation. Language is entry level artificial man.
Even if the table collapses down badly instead of doing a proper one with a good set of tools?
But the extension works, not "collapses down badly."
I can't know how To hear anymore about tables
Have you seen me work?
Yes, I build furniture for my wife’s designs. Without her my furniture wouldn’t exist. I’m the LLM in this case, capable of building things but not furniture design.
> telling someone to make a table for you is more human than making it yourself

That's a bad comparison. You have to compare crafting a table manually to doing it via CNC.

Commissioning a craftsman you respect to make custom furniture to your taste and specifications sounds human enough to me.