[scott_w]

I’m not disagreeing with that point: I’m just pointing out that the idempotency key must be persisted in your own system before the payment is submitted. Some gateways (Braintree) will let you submit no key and just give you one on request completion.

My point is that you can’t rely on this specific mechanism because request failure does not mean the payment is not going through!

I’m not sure where we disagree so I must ask: do you disagree with what I’ve written and, if so, what and why?

[jmalicki]

If the idempotency key must be persisted, that is the bookkeeping that has to occur to consider the request a success.

[scott_w]

Ok, so I’m stating that the persisting of that key must happen before the call to the payment gateway happens and regardless of whether that call succeeds or even completes. Is this something we agree on?