Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by globular-toast 41 days ago
This is such a weird complaint. "The shot" is the one where he's standing in front of the blast off. Of course the shot before it is a different shot. Who cares?
2 comments

He could have sat there repeating the same sentence over and over for several minutes.
No, because then the rocket would probably launch in the middle of the sentence. He had to start saying that sentence at the right second and pace the words and his movements perfectly.
It's not a "weird complaint" at all. The cut goes to the heart of why it's supposedly impressive. Because of the cut, all he had to do was say one sentence before the rocket lifts off (which is happening at a time that's known down to the second).
I never understood it any different, but the effect still superb IMHO.
All Paul McCartney had to was write a sequence of words to a melody beginning with the word "Yesterday".