Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by locknitpicker 45 days ago
> Ten years ago, I would have kowtowed to someone elite enough to build something like this.

I'm afraid it's an elite skill in the sense that juggling is also an elite skill. It's impressive for the first few seconds you gaze into it, but once the novelty factor wears off you understand that it's wasted effort that leads to a project that suffers from a massive maintainability problem, is limited in which platforms it can run, and brings no advantage whatsoever. It's an gimmick that has no practice use.

This is the software development equivalent of an amateur guitarist posting shredding videos on YouTube.
1 comments
fuzzy2 45 days ago
What an odd take. It is often titled "software craftsmanship". Is the craftsman not allowed to practice? Not everything needs an immediate real-world application. Not everything needs to be enterprise-grade, bulletproof, web-scale or whatever. It needs to work for the creator, and sometimes not even that.

In the same way we appreciate Japanese wood joinery, why not not just appreciate this? Someone might even learn a trick or two reading it.

link
locknitpicker 45 days ago
> What an odd take. It is often titled "software craftsmanship".

No, not really. This is exactly the opposite example of software craftsmanship. Software craftsmanship involves things like technical excellence in delivering maintainable software that is adaptable to change.

Picking assembly, of all things, for a web server represents a complete failure in the analysis of both the problem and solution domain.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_craftsmanship

This sort of project is more in line with parlour tricks, juggling, and stunt shows. Trying to frame this sort of project as software craftsman is like discussing the whole Jackass series as cinema next to Hitchcock and Scorcese. It may take skill and practice to be punched in the nuts, but that doesn't make it a craft.

link
wartywhoa23 45 days ago
> Software craftsmanship involves things like technical excellence in delivering maintainable software that is adaptable to change.

To which change, exactly?

link
pocksuppet 45 days ago
Would a craftsman not become a craftsman by honing his or her skills on seemingly pointless projects?
link