Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by skeledrew 37 days ago
Not at all. A rebellion is an organized effort, with an implicitly delayed response to grievances. I can't think of any non-humans that organize their efforts as such. It would be a heck of a thing if a group of dogs were to plan how they'd take out their masters.

All those "jobs" you describe - and many more - would cease to be a thing, as their purported basis for existence would be no more. Any role that doesn't concretely contribute to our survival and advancement is just "busy work". People could theoretically continue to maintain some simulation of something that keeps them as a retirement, but it'd be meaningless.

1 comments

> Not at all. A rebellion is an organized effort, with an implicitly delayed response to grievances. I can't think of any non-humans that organize their efforts as such. It would be a heck of a thing if a group of dogs were to plan how they'd take out their masters.

Dogs in particular are pack animals, self-organisation amongst them wouldn't be at our level but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

> All those "jobs" you describe - and many more - would cease to be a thing, as their purported basis for existence would be no more. Any role that doesn't concretely contribute to our survival and advancement is just "busy work". People could theoretically continue to maintain some simulation of something that keeps them as a retirement, but it'd be meaningless.

Yes?

I think you've missed the point, though.

When your opponent has all those skills to that level and doesn't sleep and simply applies all the surveillance tech that has already been invented like laser microphones and wall-penetrating radar that can monitor your pulse and breathing, how would you manage to rebel?

How would you find a like mind to organise with, when your opponent knows what you said marginally before the slow biological auditory cortex of the person you're talking to passes the words to their consciousness? Silicon is already that fast at this task.

And that's assuming you even want to. Propaganda and standard cult tactics observably prevent most rebellions from starting. LLMs are already weirdly effective at persuading a lot of people to act against their own interests.