[Isamu]

>Linefeed (\n) is a single byte in DOS as well.

In binary mode. In text mode if you printf(“Hello World\n”) you get CRLF because that’s how text works on DOS. Unix had the convention of only requiring the LF for text. And Unix didn’t have text/binary modes. That’s the compatibility hack on DOS.

>These control codes go back to line printers.

Back to teletypes even. Believe me, I go back to line printers.

[foresto]

I'm pretty sure that conversion was done by the C library, just as stated in the article. Not by DOS. ASCII 0x0A '\n' is always one byte*, and C library implementations for DOS would insert an ASCII 0x0D '\r' byte before it at output time if the C FILE stream had been opened in text mode.

Note that printf(), which you use in your example, is a C library function that writes writes to a predefined text mode stream. So it follows the same rules.

I wasn't able to dig up the source code of a vintage DOS compiler's C library in a few minutes of looking, so I can't prove it right now, but this section of the C standard (7.21.2 - Streams) hints that my recollection is correct:

https://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg14/www/docs/n1570.pdf#p...

*(On systems where the char type is one byte, of course, which is the case for DOS C compilers.)

[JdeBP]

I wrote a C Standard library for MS/PC/DR-DOS. Your recollection is correct.

[foresto]

Thanks for confirming!

[Isamu]

Agreed, I didn’t mean that DOS somehow converted it, this was a compatibility feature put into the C library.

[satiated_grue]

Yes, and the order is important.

Sending a carriage return and linefeed to a TTY 33 and then printing works fine. Doing them in the opposite order, if the carriage is to the right of the page, will result in a linefeed (platen rotation) happening quickly, then the carriage starting to move left to the beginning of the next line, and then the next printed character will print wherever the carriage happens to be at the time - not yet to the left. So you will be missing a character at the beginning of the line because it's in between the two lines in an unexpected column-ish.

I have run into (in my mind, "hipster") code where the programmer for some reason reversed the order of CR and LF.

[criddell]

Teletypes is what I meant to say, thank you. Line printers have no carriage return mechanism.