Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tantalor 49 days ago
No surprise there. Of course the skill files are not human written.

The AI is an expert in both following and generating prompts.

2 comments

Why do you think it is an expert in generating prompts? It has no additional insight into how it works internally than anyone else
Do you really think a random person off the street knows more about how LLMs work internally than the latest frontier model (that has been trained on that material)?
No, but a random person off the street also isn't making skills for LLMs.

I think that LLMs are trained on the millions of vibe written LLM blog posts that are more superstition than fact. There is a lot of snake oil out there that is treated as fact. If someone claims that an LLM is better than humans at something I always want to see the rigorous evaluations that have been done to quantify it, not "but they're trained on everything!"

Hmmm, I disagree. The AI is exceedingly average at everything it does and requires an expert human-in-the-loop to catch things that appear plausible but are slop. To that degree I think there is a difference between "AI generated" and slop.