[saghm]

I've always thought it would make sense for formatters to be baked into the toolchain so that they can reuse the language's parser (presumably exposed as a library) and then be implemented via parsing to AST and then formatted back out so that they're guaranteed to be correct and normalized. This doesn't seem to be how most formatters work in practice though, although I'm not sure if it's because of performance reasons or a lack of support for the parser being exposed in language toolchains.

[kevin_thibedeau]

That is essentially what clang-format is.

[saghm]

Good point, I hadn't really thought about it, but the name makes it pretty clear it's using clang's tooling. I only have worked a small amount in C++ in my career years back ago, but I distinctly remember feeling like clang-format was essentially perfect from my perspective, so it's nice to know that my abstract ideals bear out in practice.