Any reasonably good C code I ever worked with aimed to be warning free. But yes, if you can also make it an error. The flexibility is important though.
Regardless of whether you're "aiming for the code to be warning free" or telling the compiler to turn the warning into an error, you will make the implicit cast explicit and move on with your day. You've already said you should use your tools to flag these errors and that aiming to be warning free is a good thing, so I don't understand where we disagree, especially when making implicit casts explicit costs a single-digit number of keystrokes.
I was disagreeing with the statement that a "serious" language needs to have this hard-coded. think the C model where you can have the strictness if one wants to, but one can also opt-out is better.