Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mediaman 51 days ago
It has trained on vast amounts of content that contains the concept of self, of course the idea of self is emergent.

And autoregressive LLMs are not stateless.

1 comments

of course the idea of self is emergent

You sound really sure of yourself, thousands of ML researchers would disagree with you that self awareness is emergent or at all apparent in large language models. You're literally psychotic if you think this is the case and you need to go touch grass.

There is a difference between the emergence of selfawareness and the emergence of its idea. Probably
I wrote that carefully; I'd recommend you re-read more slowly it instead of calling me "psychotic" and telling me that I need to "touch grass."

Of course they have the idea of self! The millions of pages of human text contains it; it is baked into the weights, just like the knowledge of the taste of Cheetos is baked in despite their lack of any taste buds. Their knowledge of it does not mean the neural net is actually a conscious creature or truly has a self.

I assume you do not call people psychotic to their face in real life, because it's mean. Please next time take a pause and consider if there is literally any other way you could communicate your potential disagreement.