[troupo]

What tooling? It's a probabilistic text generator that runs in a black box on the provider's server. What tooling will have which guardrails to make sure that these scattered markdown files are properly injected and used in the text generation?

[strongly-typed]

That's the million dollar question. Maybe have systems of agents that all validate each other's work? Maybe something needs to be done at the harness level? I don't suppose that we could realistically expect 100% accuracy, but if we take 100% to be the upper limit, we could build systems that get us closer to that ideal.

[troupo]

This is faith in magic. "There's some magic way to make probabilistic text generator running in the cloud to never miss local files"

[strongly-typed]

No no, that’s not what I’m saying. The fact that the data is stored in files is incidental. It could be in a database, in a knowledge graph, derived from so other data Regardless of where it is, something should know to include it in the context, but only when it’s relevant.

So for instance you could start by trying to classify the prompt in some way. If you use an LLM for this, you might need to get it to return a machine parsable data format. Then your harness can pattern match on the classification and use it to enrich the prompt with additional context. The challenge would be in determining how exactly you want to go about this, balancing tradeoffs such as accuracy, cost, time, etc..

For the classification step you might begin with something like "Determine whether the following prompt is a QUESTION or a STATEMENT. Respond using only one of the two words. Prompt: $PROMPT"

You could have multiple back-and-forths like this and at each round you gain more information about the prompt, and you can use that information to determine further classifications and/or context to include.

[troupo]

> Regardless of where it is, something should know to include it in the context,

Magic. You're talking about magic. You keep re-iterating the same faith that "There's some magic way to make probabilistic text generator running in the cloud to never miss local files", where "files" is "files, knowledge graphs, databases etc.".

It doesn't matter how data is stored. You can't know when to include something relevant in the context because the whole thing including context is running in the cloud. You are not in the driver's seat. Literally anything you include locally in the prompt can and will be ignored.

[strongly-typed]

I’m not following. If I run an agent on ollama locally, it’s not in the cloud. I don’t see what cloud has anything to do with the argument.

As to your other point about anything you include in the prompt can and will be ignored. Yes, I agree. You could draw an analogy to how a teacher assigns an in-class reading assignment and follows it up with a reading comprehension quiz. If your mind wanders during the reading you may come to find that you will fail the quiz because “anything you include in the prompt can and will be ignored”. Therefore, the quiz result serves the purpose of an evaluation.