Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by olelele 47 days ago
From what I know the Islamic republic was founded in part as a reaction to US & British meddling in the internal Iranian affairs. Do you really think the US can achieve anything positive by putting troops on the ground? Have you learned nothing from Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam or Korea?
1 comments

From what I know the Islamic republic was founded in part as a reaction to US & British meddling in the internal Iranian affairs.

Yes, exactly this. The US (CIA) and Britain (MI5) were playing let's topple a government and this was the outcome. Even if indirect the end result is that we created the current mess. What I stated holds true.

Do you really think the US can achieve anything positive by putting troops on the ground?

I did not say that. I said that is the only way the desired end result is going to happen and that toppling them through technology will not work such as air strikes, electronic warfare and such. There will be mass casualties, I said that.

Have you learned nothing from Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam or Korea?

It is not up to me to learn something. If it were up to me there never would have been any kinetic wars at all. I prefer to start with economic warfare and then use discreet covert operations until they succeed. It takes longer but people are impatient and greedy. That's not my fault as far as I know.

I've enjoyed our conversation but I must get back on the gaming machine and sink some pirate ships to get my reputation up with the Brethren. Perhaps we can pick this back up tomorrow.

I'm not sure the desired outcome will be achieved. Iran is not a pushover. Good night!
I'm not sure the desired outcome will be achieved. Iran is not a pushover.

I have no idea what the actual outcome would be other than it would take a massive force and there would be significant (greater than 13%) losses. I defer such simulations to W.O.P.R. and I agree they are not push-overs. That's why every president when suggested to take them on has declined. There are some theories that have suggested they would eventually have to be taken on as part of some global reset and some global push back to the petro-dollar but they are just theories.

Just for fun, here [1] was some predictions that came very true. He's click-baity but usually right.

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4XfF5-0_X6w