I merely suggested that it is an better alternative as opposed to restricting people's freedom (and setting a precedent that the government can just simply choose to ignore people's rights).
Also criminalization of something always leads to its romanticization to some extent. Look at the rap scene. There is always a rebound effect.
There is, but we've tried educating people against smoking, and it hasn't worked. I agree with you that we shouldn't limit people's freedom, but I don't believe that education works better than criminalization, when we're talking strictly about effectiveness.
Also criminalization of something always leads to its romanticization to some extent. Look at the rap scene. There is always a rebound effect.