Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nikolay 56 days ago
This is a Linux distro, not an OS!
1 comments

And what is a Linux distro, if not an OS?
Calling a custom Linux build a brand-new OS is like a car tuner claiming they built a new car. You didn't build the engine or the chassis; you just tuned it and gave it a custom paint job. It's exactly like a hairdresser - they aren't creating a new human being, they're just cutting, coloring, and styling an existing one. It's a Linux distribution, i.e., a "distro," not a new OS!
> tuned it and gave it a custom paint job

The way to interact with the OS is significantly different from almost all other Linux distros. There is no shell, no DE. This feels like a lot more than "a custom paint job".

Is Ubuntu an OS? Mint?

Neither have built the package managment system, or the kernel, the DE(s), the utilities (maybe some but certainly not all).

What about CentOS? Or Bazzite? Or even Android?

Is macOS an OS, or "a custom BSD distro"?

And if none of those are OSs, does a Linux-based OS even exist? If not, what's the point of the distinction?

Yours is a distro. Period. When you create your own kernel, then you can make bold claims like "I created an OS," when you haven't. Be humble, and you'll be more successful. Linus Torvalds and DHH are the only two arrogant people in tech, but both have accomplished enough to earn the exception. Hubris has no place in tech!
lol what? I have no distros or OSs. You're delusional and arrogant yourself.

> Linus Torvalds and DHH are the only two arrogant people in tech

Are you feeling ok bud?

I'm very well, thank you for your sincere concern, but I can't say the same about you, unfortunately. Keep kidding yourself and use misnomers, but your command of English is poor. You can call it MisnomerOS, and that would be totally fine, but you can't claim "I've built an OS." You've built no OS.
TBF I went in expecting a novel OS.
Me, too! I first thought it was just clickbait, but then I realized it was the author's genuine thought, which is sad. I wonder why the popular Linux distro ranking site DistroWatch [0] is not called "OSWatch"! Well, I don't. The "OS" is CentOS, and NixOS is just branding. NixOS is a huge mod, yet it's still a distro!

This is what Wikipedia says about NixOS:

> NixOS is a Linux distribution built around the Nix package manager.

This is about CentOS:

> CentOS (from Community Enterprise Operating System; also known as CentOS Linux) is a discontinued Linux distribution that provided a free and open-source community-supported computing platform, functionally compatible with its upstream source, Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL).

[0]: https://distrowatch.com/

By your definitions, are there any Linux-based operating systems?
Yes - GNU/Linux [0] as Linux is just the kernel.

[0]: https://www.gnu.org/gnu/linux-and-gnu.html

Where can I get one? Also, what about Busybox-based distros?