Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hpjev 54 days ago
I would have expected better of HN. I agree that wealth and power accumulation are a problem. But the conclusion obviously isn't to have everyone forcibly DIE. If anything, this is an argument to make longevity more accessible.

The article is heavily biased against the evil tech billionaires. So much so, that it has to outright lie about Bryan Johnson? His "proprietary longevity routine" is actually fully public. The most important parts aren't some expensive surgeries but 1) regular sleep 2) healthy food 3) exercise.

Either you want everyone to live as long as possible, or you want people to die. And if the tech elites scare you that much, remember that longevity protocols protect against death by aging, _not_ assassinations.

1 comments

> I would have expected better of HN.

On a very dark night I would have expected worse.

> I agree that wealth and power accumulation are a problem. But the conclusion obviously isn't to have everyone forcibly DIE. If anything, this is an argument to make longevity more accessible.

Maybe there is some corner of the article that advocates people forcibly dying... but from skimming it, the topic is about powerful people using things like “brainless clones” to extend their lives.

The following is essentially the implied wish of this piece: I solemnly wish, with all my non-power, for tyrannical heads of states and tech billionaires to not live abnormally long.

This is what you take offense to. The wish that our overlords do not live unnaturally long.

> The article is heavily biased against the evil tech billionaires. So much so, that it has to outright lie about Bryan Johnson? His "proprietary longevity routine" is actually fully public. The most important parts aren't some expensive surgeries but 1) regular sleep 2) healthy food 3) exercise.

This I care about.

> Either you want everyone to live as long as possible, or you want people to die.

May we all live as long as possible, for it is our equal right as human beings.~

But may also tyrants and tech billionaires remain as such. For all men are not equal.

> And if the tech elites scare you that much, remember that longevity protocols protect against death by aging, _not_ assassinations.

Assassination is forcible death. Something you took offense to above.

Maybe there is some corner of the article that advocates people forcibly dying... but from skimming it, the topic is about powerful people using things like “brainless clones” to extend their lives.

This is the premise in Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go, phantastic book but really devastating.