Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by traceroute66 58 days ago
> Usually the advertised price must be honored, because it may have brought the customer to your store.

No.

In most jurisdictions this is covered by Contract Law 101 that lawyers learn in year 1.

A contract only forms when you have an offer, acceptance, consideration

The price on the shelf (or shown on the website or in a catalogue) is known as an “Invitation To Treat”.

“Invitation To Treat” means you are inviting the customer to come to you and make you an Offer. There is no obligation on the business to sell.

In the case of a supermarket in the context of this discussion, the agent scans the barcode, and the "real" price is displayed on the screen and added to your bill. This is the "Offer", the business is saying "we are willing to sell you this Tomato at this price, take it or leave it".

If you don't say anything and pay and leave, then "Acceptance" has occured and the "Consideration" is the act of payment itself.

(N.B. IANAL, so my description might not be precicely textbook, but that's the broad concept).

1 comments

That is common law, but many jurisdictions have specific regulations related to this. E.g.: https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2017/04/28/US-Pr...

I don't know whether "usually" is accurate though; it may be that common law prevails as you say in most transactions despite the states with regulations.

> it may be that common law prevails as you say in most transactions despite the states with regulations

As already mentioned IANAL, but I would take an educated guess as follows:

The specific regulations to which you refer are in effect consumer protection regulations.

Ergo, they are there to protect the consumer against malicious behaviour by unscrupulous traders such as false or misleading information.

Any reasonable judge in a courtroom will likely agree that incorrect display of pricing on a shelf (or website or catalogue) is (in the absence of evidence to the contrary) likely to be an inadvertent error with no malicious intent. And therefore the common law would prevail.