Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chromacity 58 days ago
The obvious difference is that the US, more or less by deliberate design, had a remarkably lax approach to visa overstays and illegal border crossings for decades. This resulted in a population of more than 10 million "unauthorized" residents.

Any policy that suddenly pulls the rug on them is notable precisely because we created the problem (or not-a-problem, depending on your leanings) in the first place.

2 comments

> Any policy that suddenly pulls the rug on them is notable precisely because we created the problem

Are you saying that it is wrong to ever solve a problem quickly, if you are the one who created it?

If other innocent people are collateral damage, then yes. Essentially the US "let this" happens and now wants to reverse course, but they're gonna be taking down a lot of good, hard working people with them.

Also, this will negatively affect a TON of citizens, which always sucks ass even if you think immigration is evil.

It depends on what problem and how you're "solving" it.
More accurately, half the country wants a deliberately lax approach to visa overstays and illegal border crossings, and the other half doesn't. Right now radicalized anti-immigrationists are in poltical power and they are going hard in the direction of anti-immigrant policies, under the expectation that the pro-immigration party might win the next election and attempt to reverse those policies.