Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Barbing 56 days ago
Interesting!

I know software is special. That's why software defects are acceptable while a crumbling bridge is not.

With that said, should this apply to other industries? If I clip a warehouse shelf on my first day driving a forklift, should my wages be garnished for life to cover the inventory? Or is the inherent nature of the logistics industry such that an accident does not always imply liability? (Or other)

1 comments

The employer is held liable in such a scenario.
Sounds right. Not sure if this is the position:

If you’re coding, you should pay for your mistakes, if you’re driving a forklift (sober/responsibly), your employer should pay?

If you are coding your employer pays for it too. If I take the site down and we lose $5 million I am not personally liable for that.
That mutually exclusive with our originating comment you think?:

"...I always paid for the resources I used. Just because you consume a lot of resources by accident that doesn't mean you shouldn't have to pay for it."