Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SkiFire13 107 days ago
IPv6 doesn't require modifications to IPv4 devices, applications, networks etc etc either. You just cannot reach IPv6 networks and devices from them, and the same applies to IPv8. 8to4 is nothing innovative because 6to4 already exists. In the end this proposal has all the disadvantages of IPv6 with less advantages.
1 comments

SkyFire,

This is not true, and you obviously have not read the specification. In IPv8 when a station ARPs it ARPs using ARP8 and if there is no response 50ms later it ARP4. If that station replies than IPv8 sends IPv4 packets to that station for the remainder of the ARP time out session.

Except for the r.r.r.r section of the header the rest of the payload IS ipv4.

So to encapsulate between an IPv4 network and an IPv8 network all there is from 4 to 8 add 0.0.0.0 as the source, and asn as the destination. From 8 to 4 remove the 0.0.0.0 as the ASN destination and forward the IPv4 packets.

When you need to traverse from 8 to 4 (or several 4s) to an 8 each ASN has an IPv4 anycast address that is on every IPv8 router and the packets are sent to that address, allowing them to find their way through the internet without tunnels.

It is the absolute compatibility of the payload of IPv4 and IPv8 that makes this easy and teniable.