[edoardobambini-]

Feels like a case of domain-specific optimization.

People can be extremely effective in one domain (e.g. building companies) without having a strong feedback loop for correctness in others.

Online discourse is a very different environment: - fast feedback - broad topics - low cost of being wrong

So you end up seeing a mismatch between “ability to execute in a narrow domain” and “ability to produce consistently well-calibrated opinions across many domains”.