Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by poszlem 63 days ago
I agree. Is the US still a democracy, or already an oligarchy?
2 comments

This is the point.

You can't call yourself a democracy just because we can change the colour of the same bus every 3 to 4 years

The more we treat it like a democracy, the more democratic it is. The more we treat it like an oligarchy, the less democratic it is.
Treating a rigged game as fair doesn't make it fair, it just makes you easier to beat.
> Treating a rigged game as fair doesn't make it fair, it just makes you easier to beat

Not playing at all makes you easier to beat still. Anyone pining for civil war should vacation in a war zone first. It’s difficult to encapsulate the privilege of peace until it’s been lost.

What do you say to the people in Minneapolis demanding justice for the murder of Alex Pretti?
> What do you say to the people in Minneapolis demanding justice for the murder of Alex Pretti?

Keep pushing your state investigators. Work to flip the House. And keep protesting and disrupting the browncoats.

Alex Pretti did more to stop ICE than anyone e.g. killing an individual ICE agent would do.

I am a resident of the Twin Cities and I agree wholeheartedly with this perspective. I found reading the book Waging A Good War very educational about the deliberate, strategic use of nonviolence by the American Civil Rights Movement and its ultimate triumph as a means to win support and achieve social change. It was a clear and inspiring parallel for me during the worst times of this year so far.
Brownshirts. I believe "browncoats" refers to a now-extinct space opera fandom from a few decades ago.
Civil war or getting screwed by elites aren't the only two options. That's a false dichotomy.
> Civil war or getting screwed by elites aren't the only two options. That's a false dichotomy

I completely agree. But political violence increasingly polarises the outcomes to those two. (The elites can buy gunmen faster than you or I can.)

California has a referendum system. Get an AI measure on the ballot. Companies that are doing the things Anthropic got fired for refusing to provide are banned from doing business in the State of California. (Or with the State. Find a balance that gets the votes.)