Arda was supposed to be drastically changed after the First Age. This map is from the Second/Third Ages. Do the events from the First Age map currently into what is shown? Do some have to be excluded?
Well I included 13 Silmarillion events, but most are actually Second Age events that map perfectly fine. Three of them are First age so it's a bit fudgy.
The project has no Beleriand events... they literally cannot be placed because Beleriand sank beneath the sea after the War of Wrath.
Cuiviénen it tricky. The Sea of Helcar where it sat was reshaped when Morgoth's strongholds were taken out, so that is approximate.
Would love to make age-appropriate (ha ha) maps, but I only had this one to work from.
The First Age / Second Age boundary is not unlike the K/T boundary...
Compared to that, Second Age / Third Age isn't that different (places like Dunland and Tharbad were forested, according to Treebeard). So if you wish to make the map a bit more ageless, you could just add a few alternate names.
- Dol Guldur was Amon Lanc in the Second Age
- Lothlorien was Laurelindorenan in the Second Age
- Mirkwood, Minas Tirith and Minas Morgul are late-Third-Age-isms too.